Some people have asked, "Why are we talking about oil and water together?" over the course of this year-long series. From the water shortage in Atlanta, to the high cost of gasoline, to campaigns against bottled water, we can see that oil and water are both resources under stress, but in different ways. Concerns about scarcity, availability, access, control and cost are common to both oil and water, but manifest in very different ways. Scarcity of water has different - really life-threatening - implications than does scarcity of oil, for example. We'll have a chance throughout this series and on this discussion forum to examine oil and water in terms of what scarcity means for each, what exploitation means for each, what questions we should be asking about each. We'll also take a look at the connections and interdependence between oil and water in the choices we make at the individual, community and global level. What do you think? How are oil and water connected?

Oil and Water
Is there a connection between wealth and availability of clean water? It seems as though most people who live in developing countries do not place as much importance on the quality of drinking water. Is it our job as Americans to go and assist people who do not have safe drinking water?
The easy answer to both
I do believe there is a
I do believe there is a connection between money resources and water resources in the aspect that we, as Americans, have a vast supply of drinking water, while those whom are less fortunate do no have access as quick or as formidable to the same kind of water as we do.
Although Americans are looked upon by the rest of the world as spoiled, we do have much consideration and care for those that do not have the same "luxuries." I, along with many others. would love to help provide other nations deemed developing countries with clean drinkable water.
But at the same time, I also believe that these countries must be willing to help themselves and cooperate with aide. America may be a powerful nation, but we cannot force another one to recieve our help if they do not want it. Organizations have been doing a wonderful job and saving many lives for many years, but if we really want to make a major impact we need to make diplomatic discussions and committments.
While we Americans have been born with numerous material items and extremely easy access to clean water, we are not obliged to share that with others. Though we are not required to assist others in water conflicts, I do think that if America is to be respected by the rest of the world we must share the surplus of which we have.
"Vast" Supply?
G.A.F.
As americans it is not our job to go and help people in developing countries secure safe drinking water. We should not help other countries unless we are able to gain something from helping them.
well...
Struggling Nation
Being the United States, the richest country in the world, is it our responsibility to aid struggling nations? To me this is not an apropriate question. Many foreign nations may say yes. Whenever they have problems, the first action they will take is turn to the U.S. and ask for help. For years the U.S. has responded generously by sending billions of dollars, food, water, medical supplies, national guard troops, and countless other items overseas to countries in need. But do we ever get anything in return for our generosity and effort. NO. Being one of the world "super powers", I don't see anything wrong with "aiding" another country in need. But do we always need to be the only country giving a helping hand? Do we really need to send aid and supplies for more people than are in need. But to get to the point, NO, it should not be our job to fix the rest of the world's problems. At one time, the U.S. may have been by far the wealthiest country and more than capable of helping anyone in need. However, I think that the U.S. has reached a point in which we are unable to sufficiently help others while still maintaining our own stability. Quite simply, I feel the U.S. needs to stop thinking about the well being of the rest of the world, and start thinking about ourselves for once. Economically we are in danger. We too are becoming a struggling nation. Is anyone reaching out to help us in our time of need? No one is that I am aware of. I don't want the rest of the world to think we are selfish, but the U.S. needs to worry about fixing the problems in the U.S. before it can help anyone else. This may take a while.
The way I see it is that we
The way I see it is that we have en economic problem that will eventually be solved. These nations need clean water to survive. They probably wish they had an economic problem instead of a problem that threatens their lives.
Agreed
I really do agree. Its not
I fell it is not the United
I fell it is not the United State's job to assit those in need but i believe it is what is right and should be done out of the kindness of our HEARTS!!!
It's sort of a moral
Agreed on dependent
but if we can cut that
Oil and Water
For your first question, yes, there is a connection between wealth and the availability of clean water. As for the second question, I believe the answer is a complex one...or at least made out to be complex.
Being the current leading super power, I believe we should look out for the less fortunate, similarly as the eldest sibling would for his/her brothers and sisters. However, if the eldest sibling has fallen ill (the US has increasing economical problems) then that sibling needs to recooperate before the sickness travels to the entire family. If such an event has happened, then perhaps we should hand the responsibility to the second oldest (wither that be another super power or religious volunteer communities).
well...
Why do we need topic Headings?
Kuta
"How far can a developing nation already lacking in some areas, develop further without pure, clean water?"
With a plan, any country, developed or developing, can accomplish anything. The problem with most developing countries is that they are corrupt; spending money on the wrong neccesities. If a developing country were to prioritize in a proper way, then they would realize that people of their country would collaborate better and the process of developing would become easier then what they make of it.
Yeah, yeah, yeah DAVID!
Notify? or help?
I highly doubt that
Oil and Water
I feel that our government should not have to dote on other countries and first and foremost concerns are our own. That said, philantropic NGO's could be encouraged and offered tax-exempt status to improve others countries driking water. This, way it acts as a third party with little to no interest in the geo-political aspects of thier actions. Acting indepedently of governments assures that there will be no other interests confilcting with those of the altruistic pursuit of providing clean water.
However, the country's intrest in offering pure water to it's citizens is also a factor. Many nations in the world are highly restrictive and authoriatian, and may no allow interlopers whether foregein government, or non-profit NGO. In these cases it is not ours as a nation, nor anyone elses responsibility to force their will upon them, no matter how good the intention.
good point.
Oil and Water
It is not our job as Americans to help these nations out. With the way our economy is we can no longer afford to be the nice guy in the world. I beleive it is more of a moral responsibility and what is now expected out of the U.S. however. Since we have helped out others in the past more people turn to the U.S. in their times of crisis. Unfortunately, we cannot help everyone. Some nations need to learn to do things on their own or they will forever be dependant on the United States. If the water in these countries was that bad the countries would have made it a higher priority. But right now, in developing nations in places like Africa and the Middle East, they put more emphasis on winning elections or religious law. Water is essential for survival, this is fact, yet when a country's people would rather fight with one another over a 51% to 49% election rather than secure their survival, then maybe it is not our responsibility or our job to help out the the people in developing nations. Maybe a theory should be imposed that it is their own problem, and so they will not become dependant on our dollar or our arsenal, we should not help them.
What about all the people
DAVID!
Water..
Yes, there is a connection between wealth and availbility of clean water. and that is the problem with the developing countries they do not care enough about how clean their water is. While yet their water is probably the only water they have seen and think it makes no difference to them, while others in those delevloping countries think that their water is the main sorce of their problems. It may not be our jobs as Americans to go over there and assist them in their water crisis, but as Americans we can volunteer our time, go over there and help to start to restore their water to clean water. It may have to be more of a boost in how to restore, because it is not like we have the time to help every developing country.
I don't think that
Yes, I think there is a
Yes, I think there is a definant connection to wealth ahd clean water.
I don't believe it is Americas job to assist and help people have clean drinking water. However, I think we should assist. Clean water is something that should be available to all, and I think it is very unfortunate that some people don't have access to it. Even though it may not be our job, we should go above and beyond what we are supposed to do, and that is going to make this world a better place.
So its not our job, but yet
Yes, because if it was our
We need to make sure that we are okay here too!
So you're saying that we
So you're saying that we should start something...and then not follow through??? How would our reputation look then, BOB?!??!
Let me put it this way.
Let me put it this way. If you were employed somwhere, and people depended on you to come in and do what you were supposed to do, and then one day you called in sick, you would be hurting that certain business or organization because you aren't doing your job for that day. However, if you volunteered at a local business or organization, you would be helping out when you could, and you wouldn't be hurting anyone by not being there, only helping out when you could.
Simply, it isn't Americas job to help out anyone but America, but that doesn't mean we can't do our part, and help out the rest of the world.
look at it this way.
Well lets look at it this WAY.....if you were volunteering at a local business or organization and they counted on you being there because, you had always been there before...even if you dont "feel" like being there now...wouldnt it not only ruin your reputation but also make you look like hypocrites...
It just seems ironic how in the past we always wanted to help people but now...its as if we dont care. we're all so tired of helping everyone now.
i dont think that americans should be saying that we "just cant help people" now. Obviously there has to be a limit but just stopping abruptly seems a bit contradictory.
Bam!!
I'm just saying we shouldn't officialy designated our job and responsibility to help these nations. We should help out when we can though. If it was our job to help out those nations, and we were ever in a state where we couldn't do that, it would be hurting those nations. Whereas, if we help when we can, and if a period of time goes by when we can't help they wouldn't be relying on us.
You must first help yourself before you help others. We should only take on additional responsibilities if we are 100% sure we can fullfill those duties. I am not convinced we would be able to.
Agreed
it would sort of look like
Personally, I feel that if
Personally, I feel that if the United States has the means to help others obtain cleaner water and it would not go out of our way to help them, then we should help other countries be able to use clean water as well . As a country that is by no means "too worried" about how we get our clean water, it could only be to our benefit to help other nations obtain clean water as well. We live in the 21st century and it is absolutely ridiculous to think of living in a world with others who do not have safe and nourishing water to drink.
Oil and Water!
H2O